|
|
|
| Research progress on the influencing factors for vaccine hesitancy |
| XIONG Su-juan*，JIANG Hu-da-chuan，YI Huai-ming
|
| *Changshan Hospital of Chinese Medicine，Quzhou，Zhejiang 324200，China |
|
|
|
|
Abstract Vaccine hesitation refers to the refusal or delay of vaccination when vaccination services are available and is one of the top ten threats to global health. Vaccine hesitation varies in different countries，and its influencing factors are very complex.However，domestic research on this phenomenon is still in its infancy.This article reviews the phenomenon of vaccine hesitation，the occurrence and influencing factors of vaccine hesitation in some developed countries since the 21st century，to provide the basis for taking effective measures for the phenomenon of vaccine hesitation in China.
|
|
Published: 01 November 2019
|
|
|
|
|
|
[1] DUBé E，LABERGE C，GUAY M，et al.Vaccine hesitancy[J].Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics，2014，9（8）：1763-1773.
[2] World Health Organization.Ten threats to global health in 2019[EB/OL].（2019-01-27）[2019-09-05].https：//www.who.int/emergencies/ten-threats-to-global-health-in-2019.
[3] World Health Organization.Appendices to the report of the sage working group on vaccine hesitancy[EB/OL].（2014-10-01）[2019-09-05].https：//www.who.int/immunization/sage/meetings/ 2014/october/2_SAGE_Appendicies_Background_final.pdf?ua=1.
[4] JIA R，ABRAM L W，ANNA Z，et al.The demographics of vaccine hesitancy in Shanghai，China[J].PLoS One，2019， 13（12）：e0209117.
[5] HU Y，CHEN Y，LIANG H，et al.Reliability and validity of a survey to identify vaccine hesitancy among parents in Changxing county，Zhejiang province[J].Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics，2019，15（5）：1092-1099.
[6] DOMEK G J，OLEARY S T，SHEANA B，et al.Measuring vaccine hesitancy：field testing the WHO SAGE Working Group on Vaccine Hesitancy survey tool in Guatemala[J].Vaccine，2018， 36（35）：5273-5281.
[7] LARSON H J，JARRETT C，SCHULZ W S，et al.Measuring vaccine hesitancy：the development of a survey tool[J].Vaccine，2015，33（34）：4165-4175.
[8] GREGORY A，POLAND M D A R.The age-old struggle against the antivaccinationists[J].The New England Journal of Medicne，2011，364（2）：97-99.
[9] KENNEDY A，LAVAIL K，NOWAK G，et al.Confidence about vaccines in the United States：understanding parents' perceptions[J].Health Affairs，2011，30（6）：1151-1159.
[10］ZIPPRICH J，WINTER K，HACKER J，et al.Measles outbreak-California，December 2014-February 2015[J].MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep，2015，64（6）：153-154.
[11］Center for Disease Control and Prevention.Frequently asked questions about measles in the U.S.[EB/OL].（2019-05-17）[2019- 09-05]. https：//www.cdc.gov/measles/about/faqs.html#coverage-levels.
[12］Center for Disease Control and Prevention.Measles cases in 2019[EB/OL].（2019-05-17）[2019-09-05].https：//www.cdc.gov/ measles/cases-outbreaks.html.
[13］HOFSTETTER A M，SIMON T D，LEPERE K，et al.Parental vaccine hesitancy and declination of influenza vaccination among hospitalized children[J].Hospital pediatrics，2018，8（10）：628-635.
[14］LARSON H J，FIGUEIREDO A D，ZHAO X H，et al.The state of vaccine confidence 2016：global insights through a 67-country Survey[J].EBioMedicine，2016，12：295-301.
[15］GIAMBI C，FABIANI M，D'ANCONA F，et al.Parental vaccine hesitancy in Italy：results from a national survey[J].Vaccine，2018，36（6）：779-787.
[16］JESSICA C C，HAROLD W W，JULIE L，et al.Parental immunisation needs and attitudes survey in paediatric hospital clinics and community maternal and child health centres in Melbourne，Australia[J].Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health，2018，54（5）：522-529.
[17］FORBES T A，MCMINN A，CRAWFORD N，et al.Vaccination uptake by vaccine-hesitant parents attending a specialist immunization clinic in Australia[J].Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics，2015，11（12）：2895-2903.
[18］DUBé E，GAGNON D，MACDONALD N，et al.Underlying factors impacting vaccine hesitancy in high income countries：a review of qualitative studies[J].Expert Review of Vaccines，2018， 17（11）：989-1004.
[19］KENNEDY J，MICHAILIDOU M D.Divergent policy responses to increasing vaccine scepticism in southern Europe[J].The Lancet Infectious Diseases，2017，17（9）：900.
[20］KENNEDY J.Populist politics and vaccine hesitancy in western Europe：an analysis of national-level data[J].European Journal of Public Health，2019.
[21］STUCKLER D，BASU S，SUHRCKE M，et al.The public health eff ect of economic crises and alternative policy responses in Europe：an empirical analysis[J].Lancet，2009，374（9686）：315- 323.
[22］KATA A.Anti-vaccine activists，Web 2.0，and the postmodern paradigm：an overview of tactics and tropesused online by the anti-vaccination movement[J].Vaccine，2012，30（25）：3778- 3789.
[23］LO N C，HOTEZ P J.Public health and economic consequences of vaccine hesitancy for measles in the United States[J].Jama Pediatr，2017，171（9）：887-892.
[24］PHADKE V K，BEDNARCZYK R A，SALMON D A，et al.Association between vaccine refusal and vaccine-preventable diseases in the United States：a review of measles and pertussis[J].JAMA，2016，315（11）：1149-1158.
[25］LARSON H，FLECK F.Underlying issues are key to dispelling vaccine doubts[J].Bulletin of the World Health Organization，2014，92（2）：84-85.
[26］CHUNG Y，SCHAMEL J，FISHER A，et al.Influences on immunization decision-making among US parents of young children[J].Maternal and Child Health Journal，2017，21（12）：2178- 2187.
[27］SCHWARTZ J L.Model patients and the consequences of provider responses to vaccine hesitancy[J].Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics，2013，9（12）：2663-2665.
[28］WAKEFIELD A J，MURCH S H，ANTHONY A，et al.Lleal- lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia，non-specific colitis，and pervasive developmental disorder in children[J].Lancet，1998，351（9103）：637-641.
[29］CALLENDER D.Vaccine hesitancy：more than a movement[J].Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics，2017，12（9）：2464- 2468.
[30］HOLLY O，WITTEMANA B J Z.The defining characteristics of Web 2.0 and their potential influence in the online vaccination debate[J].Vaccine，2012，30（25）：3734-3740.
[31］唐智敏，余文周，刘燕敏，等.儿童父母肠道病毒71型灭活疫苗犹豫及其影响因素分析[J].中国疫苗和免疫，2018，24（3）：334-338.
[32］JACOBSON R M，ST SAUVER J L，FINNEY RUTTEN L J.Vaccine hesitancy[J].Mayo Clinic Proceedings，2015，90（11）：1562-1568.
[33］SALMON D A，DUDLY M Z，GLANZ J M，et al.Vaccine hesitancy causes，consequences，and a call to action[J].American Journal of Preventive Medicine，2015，49（6）：391-398.
[34］GOWDA C，DEMPSEY A F.The rise（and fall?）of parental vaccine hesitancy[J].Human Vaccines，2013，9（8）：1755- 1762.
[35］FREED G L，CLARK S J，BUTCHART A T，et al.Parental vaccine safety concerns in 2009[J].Pediatrics，2010，125（4）：654.
[36］World Health Organization.Vaccine hesitancy：a growing challenge for immunization programmes[EB/OL].（2015-08-18）[2019- 09- 05]. https：//www.who.int/zh/news-room/detail/18-08-2015-vaccine-hesitancy-a-growing-challenge-for-immunization- programmes.
[37］LEASK J，WILLABY H W，KAUFMAN J.The big picture in addressing vaccine hesitancy[J].Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics，2014，10（9）：2600-2602.
[38］AJZEN I.The theory of planned behavior[J].Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes，1991，50（2）：179-211.
[39］WILLIS N，HILL S，KAUFMAN J，et al.Communicate to vaccinate：the development of a taxonomy of communication interventions to improve routine childhood vaccination[J].BMC Int Health Hum Rights，2013，13：23.
[40］JARRETT C，WILSON R，O'LEARY M，et al.Strategies for addressing vaccine hesitancy：a systematic review[J].Vaccine，2015，33（34）：4180-4190. |
|
|
|
