|
|
|
| Willingness to receive influenza vaccines among medical staff in China:a meta-analysis |
| YANG Lilin, CHEN Jianjun, LI Yi, CHEN Xinhe
|
| Taihe Hosptial (Affiliated Hospital of Hubei University of Medicine), Shiyan, Hubei 442000, China |
|
|
|
|
Abstract Objective To systematically evaluate the willingness to receive influenza vaccines among Chinese medical staff, so as to provide the evidence for developing the influenza vaccination strategy and improving the coverage of influenza vaccination among medical staff. Methods Publications pertaining to the willingness to receive influenza vaccines among Chinese medical staff were retrieved from international and national databases from January 1, 2010 to October 1, 2023, including CNKI, Wanfang Data, VIP, SinoMed, PubMed, Web of Science and Embase. A meta-analysis was performed using the software Stata 17.0, sensitivity analysis was performed using the leave-one-out method, and the publication bias was evaluated using Funnel plot. Results Totally 674 publications were retrieved, and 17 case-control studies were finally enrolled, with 23 697 participants. Meta-analysis showed that the rate of willingness to receive influenza vaccines among medical staff in China was 52.8% (95%CI: 41.3%-64.4%). The rates of willingness to receive influenza vaccines were 40.2% (95%CI: 28.5%-51.8%) in 2019 and before and 67.2% (95%CI: 56.5%-77.9%) in 2020 and beyond; 54.6% (95%CI: 44.2%-65.0%) in men and 56.8% (95%CI: 49.3%-64.4%) in women; 53.6% (95%CI: 40.9%-66.2%) in doctors, 53.9% (95%CI: 41.0%-66.8%) in nurses, 62.8% (95%CI: 46.2%-79.3%) in technicians and 53.1% (95%CI: 36.1%-70.0%) in administrative and logistical staff; 77.4% (95%CI: 63.7%-91.2%) and 43.3% (95%CI: 30.5%-56.1%) in staff with and without a history of influenza vaccination; 49.8% (95%CI: 27.3%-72.3%) and 58.3% (95%CI: 43.9%-72.6%) in studies with a sample size of <1 000 and ≥1 000, and these differences were statistically significant (all P<0.05). Sensitivity analysis showed robustness of results, and Funnel plot showed publication bias. Conclusion The rates of willingness to receive influenza vaccines among medical staff in China ranged from 41.3% to 64.4%, and were lower in studies in 2019 and before, in men, in administrative and logistical staff and in staff without a history of influenza vaccination.
|
|
Received: 15 November 2023
Revised: 08 January 2024
Published: 21 February 2024
|
|
|
|
|
|
[1] 冯录召,姜明月,伊赫亚,等.《世界卫生组织流感疫苗立场文件(2022年版)》解读[J].中华医学杂志,2022,102(30):2315-2318.
[2] Vaccines against influenza WHO positionpaper-November 2012[J].Wkly Epidemiol Rec,2012,87(47):461-476.
[3] 甘正凯,沈月根,王慎玉,等. 基层医务人员流感疫苗和23价肺炎疫苗接种相关知信行调查[J].预防医学,2019,31(12):1220-1224.
[4] 黄勋,冯录召,杜小幸,等.中国医疗机构工作人员流感疫苗预防接种指南[J].中国感染控制杂志,2023,22(8):871-885.
[5] 中国疾病预防控制中心.中国流感疫苗预防接种技术指南(2022—2023)[J].中国病毒病杂志,2023,13(1):1-19.
[6] 刘晓雪,宋祎凡,张肇南,等.2014—2021年流感季中国流感疫苗估算报告接种覆盖情况分析[J].中国病毒病杂志,2023,13(3):226-232.
[7] 周建红,沈月根,顾谢君,等.2型糖尿病患者流感疫苗和23价肺炎疫苗接种意愿调查[J].预防医学,2020,32(5):492-496.
[8] 黄玲玉,郝晓宁,薄涛,等.青岛市基层医务人员流感疫苗接种及KAP调查[J].中国公共卫生,2015,31(3):337-340.
[9] 范子亮,孙琳,杨孝坤,等.潍坊市基层医务人员流感和流感疫苗知信行状况的调查[J].预防医学论坛,2022,28(5):324-329.
[10] 曾宪涛,刘慧,陈曦,等.Meta分析系列之四:观察性研究的质量评价工具[J].中国循证心血管医学杂志,2012,4(4):297-299.
[11] 卢珊,殷娅,于静,等.开封市某医院医务人员对流感疫苗认知和接种意愿调查[J].河南预防医学杂志,2013,24(6):457-458.
[12] 王爱红,易波,申涛,等.宁波市医务人员流感疫苗接种情况及影响因素分析[J].中国公共卫生,2013,29(10):1441-1444.
[13] 高玥,赵云龙,吴华,等.北京市某三甲医院医务人员流感疫苗接种意愿及影响因素分析[J].国际病毒学杂志,2015,22(4):252-256.
[14] 袁月荣,孙灵英,蒋长征,等.基层医务人员流感疫苗接种知信行调查[J].预防医学,2017,29(11):1170-1173.
[15] 崔军,李辉,叶莉霞,等.医务人员接种和推荐接种流感疫苗意愿调查[J].预防医学,2017,29(10):1062-1066.
[16] 林颖瑜,朱婷婷,漆海亮,等.2015—2017年珠江三角洲地区医务人员四价流感疫苗接种意愿及相关因素调查[J].中华预防医学杂志,2019,53(10):1022-1026.
[17] 滕飞,黄求进,聂婉翎.哈尔滨市三甲医院医务人员流感疫苗的接种意愿及影响因素分析[J].哈尔滨医科大学学报,2020,54(1):103-105.
[18] 孔庆福,张旋,唐林,等.医疗卫生人员2019年度流感疫苗接种率和2020年度流感疫苗接种意愿及其影响因素调查[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2021,27(3):311-316.
[19] 刘刚,张敏,廖异,等.深圳市社区医生流感疫苗接种意愿及因素分析[J].中国公共卫生,2021,37(3):401-404.
[20] 亢金玲. 医护人员流感疫苗接种意愿的影响因素[J].航空航天医学杂志,2021,32(2):205-206.
[21] 张磊,胡冉,汪志国,等.江苏省医护人员流感与水痘疫苗免疫现况及接种意愿[J].江苏预防医学,2022,33(4):398-401.
[22] 胡洁,许荣全,余鹏飞,等.基层医务人员流感疫苗接种意愿及其影响因素调查(2021年)[J].国际流行病学传染病学杂志,2022,49(6):422-425.
[23] 严睿,李智,孙翔,等.2020—2021年度长三角地区医务人员流感疫苗接种意愿及其关联因素分析[J].中华预防医学杂志,2022,56(11):1571-1575.
[24] 王莹丽,蒋艳,郭丽萍,等.高风险科室医务人员接种季节性流感疫苗犹豫现状及接种意愿影响因素分析[J].中华医院感染学杂志,2022,32(2):290-294.
[25] 康霞,张慧,黄文治,等.四川省医务人员流感疫苗接种情况及相关因素分析[J].华西医学,2023,38(8):1195-1202.
[26] 佘艳,毛军,邵海贤,等.上海市陆家嘴社区6月龄~6岁儿童流感疫苗的接种率及影响因素分析[J].上海医药,2022,43(6):40-44.
[27] HAN K,FRANCIS M R,XIA A,et al.Influenza vaccination uptake and its determinants during the 2019-2020 and early 2020-2021 flu seasons among migrants in Shanghai,China:a cross-sectional survey[J].Hum Vaccin Immunother,2022,18(1):1-8.
[28] 周凤先,徐蓉,周晓飞,等.高危人群对甲型H1-N1流感医院感染控制认知调查分析[J].华西医学,2009,24(10):2621-2624.
[29] 随海田,杨中楠,苏锦锋,等.中国部分非国家免疫规划疫苗国内外接种现状及免疫策略[J].公共卫生与预防医学,2022,33(5):7-12.
[30] 李巧巧,杨义,马厚芝,等.医务人员流感疫苗免费接种措施实施效果评价及改进建议[J].实用预防医学,2021,28(9):1111-1113.
[31] CORACE K M,SRIGLEY J A,HARGADON D P,et al.Using behavior change frameworks to improve healthcare worker influenza vaccination rates:a systematic review[J].Vaccine,2016,34(28):3235-3242.
[32] JIA W Y,ZHANG X,SUN R Y,et al.Effective measures to improve influenza vaccination coverage among healthcare workers during and after COVID-19[J/OL].Hum Vaccin Immunother,2023,19(3)[2024-01-08].https://doi.org/10.1080/21645515.2023.2289243.
[33] BIANCHI F P,STEFANIZZI P,CUSCIANNA E,et al.Effectiveness of on-site influenza vaccination strategy in Italian healthcare workers:a systematic review and statistical analysis[J].Expert Rev Vaccines,2023,22(1):17-24. |
|
|
|
