新冠肺炎疫情期间医务人员焦虑状况的Meta分析

doi:10.19485/j.cnki.issn2096-5087.2022.07.015

Preventive Medicine

2022, Vol. 34

Issue (7): 720-726 DOI: 10.19485/j.cnki.issn2096-5087.2022.07.015

Disease Control

Current Issue | Archive | Adv Search

Prevalence of anxiety among healthcare professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic: a meta-analysis

SHEN Qiang, ZHANG Yueqin, JIANG Shengjie, GAN Lu, WEI Yingying

Department of Medical Administration, Hangzhou Women's Hospital, Hangzhou, Zhejiang 310008, China

Abstract
Figure/Table
References
Related Citation (15)

Download: PDF (1121 KB) HTML (0 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract Objective To systematically investigate the prevalence of anxiety among healthcare professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic, so as to provide the development of evidence-based psychological interventions among healthcare professionals. Methods The publications pertaining to the prevalence of anxiety among healthcare professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic were retrieved in national and international electronic databases from January 1, 2020 through November 30, 2021, including CNKI, Wanfang Data, VIP, SinoMed, PubMed and Web of Science. The quality of publications was evaluated using the United States Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) quality assessment of included cross-sectional studies, and the pooled prevalence of anxiety was estimated among healthcare professionals using the software Open Meta Analyst version 3.0. The publication bias were evaluated with funnel plots and Begg rank correlation test. Results Totally 598 publications were retrieved, and 36 eligible publications were enrolled in the final analysis, including 33 Chinese publications and 3 English publications. There were 5 high-quality, 29 moderate-quality and 2 low-quality publications. All investigations pertaining to the prevalence of anxiety among healthcare professionals were conducted in 2020. Totally 19 872 healthcare professionals were investigated, and the prevalence of anxiety was 28.8% (95%CI: 24.0%-33.6%). Subgroup analysis showed that the prevalence of anxiety was 31.9% (95%CI: 17.6%-46.2%) among healthcare professionals from western China, 29.6% (95%CI: (17.8%-41.4%) from central China, and 25.3% (95%CI: 20.2%-30.3%) from eastern China. The prevalence of anxiety was 4.9% (95%CI: 3.3%-6.4%) among male healthcare professionals and 22.9% (95%CI: 17.7%-28.0%) among male healthcare professionals, and the prevalence of anxiety was 21.6% (95%CI: 13.2%-29.9%) among nurses, 5.2% (95%CI: 2.8%-7.5%) among doctors and 4.8% (95%CI: 2.2%-7.4%) among other healthcare professionals. The prevalence of mild, moderate and severe anxiety was 18.6% (95%CI: 14.0%-23.2%), 5.5% (95%CI: 4.1%-6.8%) and 1.9% (95%CI: 1.3%-2.5%), respectively. No publication bias was detected as revealed by funnel plots and Begg rank correlation test, and stable meta-analysis results and heterogeneity test were observed. Conclusions The prevalence of anxiety is 28.8% among healthcare professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic, and mild anxiety is predominant. A high prevalence rate of anxiety is seen female healthcare professionals and nurses, who should be given a high priority and timely psychological interventions

Key words： COVID-19 healthcare professional anxiety meta-analysis

Received: 29 December 2021 Revised: 22 April 2022 Published: 19 July 2022

ZTFLH:

R749.92

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	SHEN Qiang
	ZHANG Yueqin
	JIANG Shengjie
	GAN Lu
	WEI Yingying

Cite this article:

SHEN Qiang,ZHANG Yueqin,JIANG Shengjie, et al. Prevalence of anxiety among healthcare professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic: a meta-analysis[J]. Preventive Medicine, 2022, 34(7): 720-726.

URL:

http://www.zjyfyxzz.com/EN/10.19485/j.cnki.issn2096-5087.2022.07.015 OR http://www.zjyfyxzz.com/EN/Y2022/V34/I7/720

[1] Eurosurveillance Editorial Team.Note from the editors:World Health Organization declares novel coronavirus(2019-nCoV)sixth public health emergency of international concern[J/OL].Euro Surveill,2020,25(5)[2022-04-22].http://doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.5.200131e.
[2] 刘峥嵘,张旭东,吕芷菡,等.COVID-19流行期间广东省普通群众及医务人员心理状况对比及影响因素调查[J].南方医科大学学报,2020,40(10):1530-1538.
LIU Z R,ZHANG X D,LÜ Z H,et al.Mental health status and its influencing factors among general population and medical personnel in Guangdong Province during COVID-19 pandemic[J].J South Med Univ,2020,40(10):1530-1538.
[3] 张瑶,郭慧荣,吕培培,等.COVID-19流行期间医务人员的心理健康调查及分析[J].河南医学研究,2020,29(26):4801-4805.
ZHANG Y,GUO H R,LÜ P P,et al.Investigation and analysis on mental health of medical personnel during the Corona Virus Disease 2019 outbreak[J].Henan Med Res,2020,29(26):4801-4805.
[4] 刘向来,林展,朱洪,等.海南省援鄂抗击新型冠状病毒肺炎医务人员心理健康状况分析[J].海南医学院学报,2020,26(17):1285-1288.
LIU X L,LIN Z,ZHU H,et al.Investigation of mental health status of medical stuff from Hainan who aided Hubei province to fight against COVID-19[J].J Hainan Med Univ,2020,26(17):1285-1288.
[5] 吴亚平,张露远,李红英,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎疫情下不同岗位医务人员的心理状况及应对策略分析[J].中国血液流变学杂志,2020,30(2):253-258.
WU Y P,ZHANG L Y,LI H Y,et al.Analysis of psychological status and coping strategies of medical staff in different positions under the new coronavirus pneumonia epidemic[J].Chin J Hemorh,2020,30(2):253-258.
[6] ROSTOM A,DUBÉ C,CRANNEY A,et al.Appendix D.Quality assessment forms[M/OL]//Evidence reports/technology assessments,No.104.Rockville:Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality,2004[2022-04-22].http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK35156.
[7] 东保吉,袁媛,王丽霞,等.抗击新型冠状病毒肺炎一线护理人员职业心理情况的调查分析[J].新疆医科大学学报,2020,43(3):273-275.
DONG B J,YUAN Y,WANG L X,et al.Discussion on the first-line nurses' psychological state and prevention strategies of fighting against COVID-19[J].J Xinjiang Med Univ,2020,43(3):273-275.
[8] 周晓平,黄继峥,任阿可,等.某市1 426名新冠肺炎抗疫一线医务人员心理应对能力调查[J].中国感染控制杂志,2021,20(4):320-325.
ZHOU X P,HUANG J Z,REN A K,et al.Psychological coping ability of 1 426 health care workers participating in first-line anti-epidemic of COVID-19 in a city[J].Chin J Infect Control,2021,20(4):320-325.
[9] 邢红叶,王春英,夏雅雄,等.宁波市新型冠状病毒肺炎隔离病房护士焦虑与抑郁状况调查及影响因素分析[J].现代实用医学,2020,32(12):1533-1534.
XING H Y,WANG C Y,XIA Y X,et al.Survey on anxiety and depression among nurses in isolation ward against COVID-19 in Ningbo and influencing factors[J].Mod Pract Med,2020,32(12):1533-1534.
[10] 赵亚军,张房艳,葛许华,等.全科医生在社区防控新型冠状病毒肺炎中的困难和需求及心理状况调查研究[J].全科医学临床与教育,2020,18(3):240-244.
ZHAO Y J,ZHANG F Y,GE X H,et al.Survey on the difficulties,requirements and psychological status of general practitioners in community-based prevention and control of the COVID-19 epidemic[J].Clin Educ Gen Pract,2020,18(3):240-244.
[11] 何碧玉,万和平.上海市社区防疫医务人员心理状态及影响因素分析[J].心理月刊,2021,16(4):13-16.
HE B Y,WAN H P.Analysis on psychological status and influencing factors of Shanghai community epidemic prevention medical personnel[J].Chin J Psychol,2021,16(4):13-16.
[12] 张瑶,张西京,彭嘉熙,等.武汉抗新型冠状病毒肺炎医务人员心理健康调查[J].热带医学杂志,2020,20(10):1371-1374.
ZHANG Y,ZHANG X J,PENG J X,et al.A survey on mental health of medical staff fighting COVID-19 in Wuhan[J].J Trop Med,2020,20(10):1371-1374.
[13] 蒲昭谦,周丽,田玲,等.新冠病毒肺炎低发地区疫情期间一线医务人员和公务员的心理状态调查及干预对策[J].中国卫生事业管理,2021,38(5):390-394.
PU Z Q,ZHOU L,TIAN L,et al.Surveying The mental state of medical staffs and civil servants in frontline of low-incidence areas of COVID-19 and its intervention countermeasures[J].Chin Health Serv Manag,2021,38(5):390-394.
[14] 周芳,王耀州,杨媛媛,等.新冠肺炎爆发期间不同等级医院儿科医护人员焦虑和抑郁情绪的比较分析[J].国际精神病学杂志,2020,47(5):866-870.
ZHOU F,WANG Y Z,YANG Y Y,et al.A comparative analysis of the anxiety and depression symptom among pediatric medical staff in different grade hospitals during the outbreak of neocoronary pneumonia[J].J Int Psychiatry,2020,47(5):866-870.
[15] 王珊珊,余文婷,黄秦,等.新冠肺炎爆发期间医务人员的心理健康状况及与正负性情绪的关系[J].心理学进展,2021,11(1):168-175.
WANG S S,YU W T,HUANG Q,et al.Mental health status of public and medical staff's relationship with positive and negative emotion during novel coronavirus disease epidemic:an online survey[J].Adv Psychol,2021,11(1):168-175.
[16] 李颖,赵贺,朱雪泉,等.新冠肺炎定点收治医院和精神专科医院医务人员心理状况调查[J].临床精神医学杂志,2020,30(6):434-437.
LI Y,ZHAO H,ZHU X Q,et al.Analytical report of mental health status of medical staff in a designated COVID-19 hospital and a psychiatric hospital[J].J Clin Psychiatry,2020,30(6):434-437.
[17] 雷雨,王楠,翟红.新冠肺炎集中医学观察点医务人员的心理状况分析[J].现代医药卫生,2021,37(9):1600-1603.
LEI Y,WANG N,ZAI H.Analysis of the psychological status of medical staff in cluster medical observation site against COVID-19[J]. J Mod Med Health,2021,37(9):1600-1603.
[18] 周延,周浩,赵魏情,等.新冠肺炎疫情暴发期间基层医务人员心理健康调查分析[J].中国研究型医院,2020,7(2):27-30.
ZHOU Y,ZHOU H,ZHAO W Q,et al.Analysis of the mental health of primary healthcare workers during the outbreak of Corona Virus Disease 2019[J].J Chin Res Hosp,2020,7(2):27-30.
[19] 孙振晓,于相芬.新冠肺炎疫情期间封闭管理精神科医护人员焦虑抑郁症状及相关因素调查[J].四川精神卫生,2020,33(2):102-106.
SUN Z X,YU X F.Anxiety and depression symptoms and related factors of medical staff in closed-door psychiatric ward during COVID-19 outbreak[J].Sichuan Ment Health,2020,33(2):102-106.
[20] 吴春艳,徐继,沈国樑,等.新冠肺炎疫情期间规范化培训住院医师焦虑和抑郁状况调查[J].中国高等医学教育,2020(11):28-29.
WU C Y,XU J,SHEN G L,et al.Anxiety and depression status of residents undergoing for standardized training during COVID-19[J].China High Med Educ,2020(11):28-29.
[21] 燕银枝,喻俊,陈立勇,等.新冠肺炎疫情期间医务工作者消极情绪与应激的关系研究[J].中国社区医师,2021,37(4):57-58.
YAN Y Z,YU J,CHEN L Y,et al.The relationship between negative emotion and stress in medical worker during the outbreak of novel coronavirus pneumonia[J].Chin Community Doct,2021,37(4):57-58.
[22] 潘宁,王艳娜,张晋昕,等.新冠肺炎疫情期间医务人员抑郁焦虑情绪和失眠现况及其影响因素[J].环境与职业医学,2021,38(6):624-629.
PAN N,WANG Y N,ZHANG J X,et al.Prevalence and related factors of depression,anxiety,and insomnia among medical staff during COVID-19 pandemic[J].J Environ Occup Med,2021,38(6):624-629.
[23] 李娟娟,韩超汝,杜仪,等.新冠肺炎疫情下发热门诊医务工作者的心理状态分析及应对策略[J].临床和实验医学杂志,2020,19(12):1256-1259.
LI J J,HAN C R,DU Y,et al.Analysis of psychosocial characteristics of outpatient medical workers with fever caused by COVID-19 and its countermeasures[J].J Clin Exp Med,2020,19(12):1256-1259.
[24] 梅莉,梅佩,李琴.新冠肺炎疫情下首批一线医务人员心理状态及应对方式现状调查[J].齐鲁护理杂志,2020,26(13):40-43.
MEI L,MEI P,LI Q.Survey on psychological status and coping style of first-line medical staff during COVID-19[J].J Qilu Nurs,2020,26(13):40-43.
[25] 马明芳,肖瑾,辛霞.新冠肺炎疫情下一线医务人员心理健康状态分析及应对策略[J].中国医学伦理学,2021,34(4):496-499.
MA M F,XIAO J,XIN X.Analysis and coping ctrategies of mental health status of first-line medical staff under COVID-19[J].Chin Med Ethics,2021,34(4):496-499.
[26] 张宴萍,褚连芳,庄开岑,等.新冠肺炎疫情下医务人员压力、焦虑、抑郁状况及影响因素研究[J].现代预防医学,2021,48(1):38-43.
ZHANG Y P,CHU L F,ZHUANG K C,et al.Stress,anxiety,depressionand relevant factors of health staff during COVID-19 epidemic period[J].Mod Prev Med,2021,48(1):38-43.
[27] 戴宁彬,胡一河,华钰洁,等.新冠疫情期间苏州医务人员心理健康状况及影响因素分析[J].江苏预防医学,2021,32(1):35-38.
DAI N B,HU Y H,HUA Y J,et al.Mental health status and influencing factors among medical personnel in Suzhou in the COVID-19 outbreak[J].Jiangsu J Prev Med,2021,32(1):35-38.
[28] 韦红恩,宁俐文,曾宪锋,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎定点医院医务人员焦虑抑郁纵向研究[J].河南医学研究,2021,30(21):3841-3846.
WEI H E,NING L W,ZENG X F,et al.Anxiety and depression among medical staffs in Corona Virus Disease 2019 designated hospitals:a longitudinal study[J].Henan Med Res,2021,30(21):3841-3846.
[29] 宋婷,李凯,刘艳,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎期间皮肤科医务人员的焦虑情绪分析[J].延安大学学报(医学科学版),2021,19(1):26-28.
SONG T,LI K,LIU Y,et al.Anxiety status among dermatological medical staff during the outbreak of novel coronavirus pneumonia[J].J Yanan Univ(Med Sci) ,2021,19(1):26-28.
[30] 赵玉荣,吴芳芳,储晶晶,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎期间医务人员心理健康状况及其影响因素分析[J].中南医学科学杂志,2021,49(1):100-105.
ZHAO Y R,WU F F,CHU J J,et al.Analysis of psychological health status and influencing factors of medical staff during COVID-19[J].Med Sci J Cent South China,2021,49(1):100-105.
[31] 韩静,王娟,陈擎仪,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎疫情暴露与非湖北一线医务人员心理健康的关系[J].心理月刊,2020,18(15):17-20.
HAN J,WANG J,CHEN Q Y,et al.The relationship between COVID-19 exposure and mental health of medical staff not working in Hubei during the outbreak[J].Chin J Psychol,2020,18(15):17-20.
[32] 徐薇薇,许小明,钟际香,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎疫情期间一线医务人员认知行为及心理卫生调查[J].实用预防医学,2021,28(2):161-165.
XU W W,XU X M,ZHONG J X,et al.Survey on cognitive behavior and mental health of medical professionals at the front line during COVID-19 epidemic[J].Pract Prev Med,2021,28(2):161-165.
[33] 王琳,王建红,李晓萌,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎疫情期间医务人员及其子女心理应激反应调查分析[J].教育生物杂志,2020,8(3):160-165.
WANG L,WANG J H,LI X M,et al.Analysis of psychological stress response of medical staff and their children during corona virus disease 2019 outbreak[J].J Bio-edu,2020,8(3):160-165.
[34] 张智甡,邹少木,王淼,等.COVID-19常态化疫情防控期间定点收治医院医务人员心理健康状况调查及分析[J].心理月刊,2020,18(15):54-55.
ZHANG Z S,ZOU S M,WANG M,et al.Investigation and analysis of mental health status of medical staff in designated hospitals during COVID-19 normalized epidemic prevention and control[J].Chin J Psychol,2020,18(15):54-55.
[35] 张宁,屈云飞,史文新,等.新型冠状病毒肺炎流行期间某院一线医护人员焦虑抑郁状况[J].中国健康心理学杂志,2020,28(12):1825-1828.
ZHANG N,QU Y F,SHI W X,et al.Anxiety and depression of front-line medical staff in our hospital during the period of COVID-19 epidemic[J].Chin J Health Psychol,2020,28(12):1825-1828.
[36] AWANO N,OYAMA N,AKIYAMA K,et al.Anxiety,depression and resilience of healthcare workers in Japan during the coronavirus disease 2019 outbreak[J].Intern Med,2020,59:2693-2699.
[37] AZOULAY E,POCHARD F,REIGNIER J,et al.Symptoms of mental health disorders in critical care physicians facing the second COVID-19 wave:a cross-sectional study[J].Chest,2021,160(3):944-955.
[38] CONTI C,FONTANESI L,LANZARA R,et al.Burnout status of Italian healthcare workers during the first COVID-19 pandemic Peak Period[J/OL].Healthcare,2021,9(5)[2022-04-22].https://doi.org/10.3390/healthcare9050510.